Navigation Links
Avian origins: new analysis confirms ancient beginnings
Date:2/5/2008

ANN ARBOR, Mich.---Did modern birds originate around the time of the dinosaurs' demise, or have they been around far longer"

The question is at the center of a sometimes contentious "rocks versus clocks" debate between paleontologists, whose estimates are based on the fossil record, and scientists who use "molecular clock" methods to study evolutionary history.

A new analysis by researchers at the University of Michigan, the University of Chicago, the Centre for Biodiversity Conservation Mexico and Central America, and Boston University offers the strongest molecular evidence yet for an ancient origin of modern birds, suggesting that they arose more than 100 million years ago, not 60 million years ago, as fossils suggest.

The research was published online Jan. 28 in the journal BMC Biology.

"Scientists typically use two sources of information to date biological events: the fossil record, which contains physical remains of ancient organisms, and molecular genetic data," said graduate student Joseph Brown, who is first author on the paper. In the case of modern birds, however, the two approaches have yielded conflicting results, at times leading to heated debates between paleontologists and molecular biologists. Molecular biologists have asserted that the fossil record must be incomplete, while paleontologists have countered that the genetic data must be suspect.

In fact, both approaches have their weaknesses, Brown said. Fossils tend to underestimate how much time has passed since lineages diverged. That's because fossils preserve only evidence of changes in outward physical appearance, and such changes take some time to accumulate after the actual "speciation event" that marks the divergence.

As for genetic data, the so-called molecular clock isn't quite as precise as once thought. The approach relies on the observation that although mutations occur at random in the genome, when looked at over long stretches of time they occur (or "tick") at a fairly constant rate. Molecular biologists use that rate to reconstruct evolutionary history.

"If we know, for example, that DNA sequences diverge by an average of two percent every million years, and we determine that two species differ genetically by ten percent, we can figure out that they last shared a common ancestor five million years ago," Brown said. The problem is, "different lineages can 'tick' at different rates, so applying a single rate to an entire tree could lead to very suspect results."

Fortunately, new methods exist for compensating for differing rates.

"What my colleagues and I did was apply all of these new methods to the problem of the origin of modern birds, with each method making different assumptions about how mutation rate changes across the tree," Brown said. He hoped the analysis would narrow the gap between fossil and molecular data, but in fact it only reinforced the rock-clock split by underscoring the finding that modern birds arose more than 100 million years ago.

So where does that leave the contentious camps of scientists trying to solve the puzzle of how the world's 10,000 bird species came about"

"Rather than fighting across groups, we now have the joint goal of explaining this rock-clock gap," Brown said. "Resolution of the issue will be fertile ground for future research for a while to come."


'/>"/>

Contact: Nancy Ross-Flanigan
rossflan@umich.edu
734-647-1853
University of Michigan
Source:Eurekalert

Related biology news :

1. MIT finds key to avian flu in humans
2. Smiths Detection to launch a portable diagnostic system for foot-and-mouth disease and avian flu
3. New field-deployable biosensor detects avian influenza virus in minutes instead of days
4. Analysis calls for medical device information to better serve patients and doctors
5. More comprehensive analysis of Klamath River basin needed to aid decision makers
6. Human clones: New U.N. analysis lays out worlds choices
7. Powerful integration of lipid metabolic profiling with gene expression analysis
8. Tumor genome analysis unveils new insights into lung cancer
9. Analysis of breast and colon cancer genes finds many areas of differences between tumors
10. Interacting protein theory awaits test from new neutron analysis tools
11. DNA analysis shows true dispersal of protozoa
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:3/9/2017)... , March 9, 2017 4Dx has publicly ... Lung Imaging Workshop at the University of Pennsylvania. Founder ... to deliver the latest data to world leaders in ... brings together leaders at the forefront of the industry ... imaging. "The quality of the imaging ...
(Date:3/6/2017)... SAN MATEO, Calif. , March 6, 2017 ... predictive marketing and sales technology, today announced Predictive ... (AI) solution for infusing actionable sales intelligence into ... customers to automatically enable their sales organizations with ... contextual messages that allow for intelligent engagement. Predictive ...
(Date:3/2/2017)... , March 2, 2017 Australian stem ... (ASX: CYP), has signed an agreement with the ... the Monash Biomedicine Discovery Institute and Department of Pharmacology ... conduct a further preclinical study to support the use ... of asthma.  Asthma is a chronic, ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):
(Date:3/23/2017)... LOUISVILLE, Colo. , March 23, 2017  GlobeImmune, ... purchase agreement for the sale of 12,835,490 shares of ... the  NantWorks  ecosystem of companies. In connection with the sale ... GlobeImmune $100,000 in cash and issue to GlobeImmune 200,000 ... common stock. "We are pleased to ...
(Date:3/23/2017)... ... 23, 2017 , ... Ellen Matloff, president and CEO of ... as a 2017 Women of Innovation® finalist. Matloff will be among several women ... The dinner recognizes women accomplished in science, technology, engineering and math (STEM), along ...
(Date:3/23/2017)... 23, 2017 NetworkNewsWire Editorial Coverage  ... Cancer remains ... strain on health care systems, in terms of costs and ... too does the development of innovative and efficient therapies that ... the many types of cancer treatments, a growing number of ...
(Date:3/23/2017)...  Agriculture technology company Cool Planet has closed on ... to commercialize its Cool Terra and Cool Fauna Engineered ... that are simultaneously profitable as well as sustainable and ... months. This latest round of funding was led by ... The company,s primary product, Cool Terra, can improve ...
Breaking Biology Technology: