Navigation Links
A re-review of peer review: Leading journal looks to end the 'review nightmare'
Date:1/27/2009

Every scientific researcher has asked themselves the question at some stage in their professional career: Why has the paper I submitted to be peer reviewed disappeared into the ether?

Scientists, like most people, desire immediate results. In the case of peer review, researchers want to learn whether their paper has been accepted or rejected as soon as possible. Unfortunately, the review process rarely seems to work in this manner, even with the enhancements that the Internet has bought.

The primary source of frustration for authors is peer reviewers who insist on time-consuming and sometimes iterative re-review that makes little difference to the eventual validity or quality of the final research paper. For that reason, Journal of Biology is today embarking on an experimental policy of allowing authors to opt out of re-review in an effort to dramatically speed up the publication process.

Led by Miranda Robertson, the newly appointed Editor of Journal of Biology and a former Biology Editor at Nature, the new policy will see all research papers submitted to Journal of Biology first screened by a member of the Editorial Board for suitability of inclusion into the journal. If any of the reviewers then has suggestions or demands revisions, including the addition of data, authors will be asked to respond to the referees and revise the manuscript.

However, under the new experimental policy, the authors will then be able to decide whether or not they wish the referees to look at their manuscripts again.

Where authors opt out of re-review their responses and the editors will carefully scrutinize revised manuscripts and if it is clear that substantive issues have not been addressed then the manuscript may be rejected. Otherwise it will be published, with an accompanying minireview in which any flaws in the paper may be highlighted.

The decision to launch this experiment was taken after consultation with members of the Editorial Board, who were in general emphatically supportive of this new policy. 'Something surely needs to be done about the review nightmare that so many people face' said Editorial Board Member, Arthur Lander, University of California San Diego'what is in the paper is fundamentally the responsibility of the authors, not of the reviewers' added Robert Horvitz, Massachusetts Institute of Technology and Nobel Laureate.

Speaking of the launch of the policy, Miranda Robertson said 'Of course journals must do their best to ensure that the research they publish is valid, but the primary function of a journal editor is to promote the dissemination of research results, not to obstruct it. I hope this experiment will show that referees, authors and journals can work together to accelerate the publication of important research.'


'/>"/>

Contact: Matt McKay
matthew.mckay@biomedcentral.com
44-020-707-94845
BioMed Central
Source:Eurekalert

Related biology news :

1. M2SYS Partners with SecuGen Corporation to Support Market Leading Hamster Plus Fingerprint Reader with Auto-On Technology
2. Leading experts cite poor health and nutrition as major barrier to education in developing world
3. Ossur -- leading orthopedic pioneer - expands network to Asia
4. Leading researchers to reveal comprehensive dos and donts for prostate cancer
5. BIO-key(R) PocketCop(R) Project Leading the Nation According to Televised Report
6. Are current projections of climate change-impacts on biodiversity misleading?
7. Cleveland Clinic leading clinical program to improve early-stage lung cancer detection
8. Leading cause of death in preemies might be controlled by resetting a molecular switch
9. Leading researchers and experts gather to discuss latest advancements in drug discovery
10. World-leading journal publishes special issue on UN/GA
11. Research leading to tools for managing bovine respiratory disease complex
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:3/7/2017)... LAKE CITY , March 7, 2017   ... that help top global companies identify the best talent, ... as Chief Sales Officer (CSO) and Diana ... Kucer,s appointments round out a seasoned executive team poised to ... and beyond, building on a year of record bookings ...
(Date:3/2/2017)... -- Summary This report provides all the information ... and activities since 2010. ... Read the full report: http://www.reportlinker.com/p03605615-summary/view-report.html ... provides an in-depth insight into the partnering activity of one ... demand company reports are prepared upon purchase to ensure inclusion ...
(Date:3/2/2017)... -- Who risk to be deprived of its imprint ... https://www.reportbuyer.com/product/4313699/ WILL APPLE AND SAMSUNG CONFRONT ... sensors using capacitive technology represent a fast growing market, ... an increase of 360% of the number of fingerprint ... sensor market between 2014 and 2017 (source : N+1 ...
Breaking Biology News(10 mins):
(Date:3/29/2017)... March 29, 2017  Applied BioMath ( ... modeling to drug research and development, today ... Zymeworks Inc. for quantitative systems pharmacology (QSP) ... for the treatment of cancer. ... for GLP toxicology studies and first-in-human dose ...
(Date:3/29/2017)... ... 2017 , ... Bactana Animal Health, a company developing natural products aimed at ... of the gut microbiota, today announced the closing of its first round of funding. ... Income Capital Management, LLC and a number of private investors. The company will use ...
(Date:3/29/2017)... , Mar. 29, 2017 Research ... Biotechnology: Emerging Technologies and Global Markets" report to their ... ... next generation DNA sequencing, biochips, RNA interference, synthetic biology tools ... seeds; and biologicals. These technologies and products are ...
(Date:3/28/2017)... ... March 28, 2017 , ... Franz Inc ., the leading supplier ... has been named a ‘Champion’ by Bloor Research in its recent Graph Database ... its class, and, thanks to Gruff, it was rated as the easiest product to ...
Breaking Biology Technology: